Stay or Sell? How To Make the Right Call as You Age

Stay or Sell? How To Make the Right Call as You Age

  • Anthony D'Alicandro
  • 04/29/26

Can You Stay in Your Home Long-Term… or Does It Make More Sense To Move?

At some point, almost every homeowner starts thinking about the years ahead and asks a simple question:

“Can I stay here long-term… or does it make more sense to move?”

For most people, the answer is clear.

They want to stay.

In fact, research from the USC Leonard Davis School of Gerontology shows nearly 90% of homeowners over 65 prefer to remain in their homes as they get older.

And that makes sense.

Your home is familiar.
It’s comfortable.
And it holds years—sometimes decades—of memories.

But while staying may feel like the right answer emotionally, it’s still worth thinking through what that actually looks like over time.


What Staying in Your Home Really Means

Aging in place is absolutely possible.

But in most cases, it doesn’t happen without some level of planning.

The home that worked perfectly 10 or 20 years ago may need to evolve with you. And that usually means making updates along the way.

Some are simple:

  • Adding grab bars in bathrooms
  • Improving lighting
  • Reducing trip hazards

Others are more involved:

  • Reworking layouts
  • Moving key living spaces to the first floor
  • Addressing stairs or accessibility challenges

And while some of these changes are manageable, others can become a meaningful financial investment.

That’s why thinking about it early matters.

Not because you need to make a decision today—but because it gives you time:

  • Time to understand what your home may need
  • Time to explore your options
  • Time to plan for costs and space them out
  • Time to make thoughtful decisions instead of reactive ones

Why So Many Homeowners Still End Up Moving

Here’s the interesting part—especially in markets like Philadelphia and South Jersey.

Even though most homeowners say they want to stay, a large percentage of the homes that actually come on the market are still being sold by Gen X and Baby Boomers.

That’s not a contradiction.

It’s just how life works.

Because when you have the largest group of homeowners in the country, even a small percentage deciding to move turns into a significant number of homes being sold.

And those decisions are rarely sudden.

They tend to happen gradually, as needs change over time.

Sometimes it’s:

  • Maintenance or upkeep becoming more difficult
  • A layout that no longer fits day-to-day life
  • A desire to be closer to family
  • Or simply wanting to simplify and reduce responsibility

Other times, it’s more about lifestyle than necessity.

Some homeowners just don’t want to take on major renovation projects. Others realize there are options—like downsizing or moving to a more manageable home—that better fit this next chapter.


Staying vs. Moving: There’s No Right Answer

Some homeowners stay and adapt their homes over time.

Others decide that moving is the simpler, more practical solution.

Both are valid.

The goal isn’t to decide today—it’s to understand your options early so you’re not forced into a decision later.


A Smarter Way To Think About It

Whether you’re in Philadelphia, the surrounding suburbs, or anywhere across South Jersey, the homeowners who feel the most confident about their decisions are the ones who plan ahead.

They don’t wait for a moment of urgency.

They take the time to:

  • Understand what their home may need long-term
  • Evaluate the cost of staying vs. moving
  • Think about how each option impacts their lifestyle and equity

Because the best decisions aren’t made under pressure.

They’re made with clarity.


Bottom Line

Most people want to stay in their homes—and many do.

But for others, the right move eventually becomes something different.

The key is giving yourself the time and information to make that decision on your terms.

If this is something you’ve started thinking about, even just a little, it’s worth having a conversation.

I can help you look at what your home might need, what those updates could cost, and how both staying or moving could impact your position in the Philadelphia and South Jersey market.

That way, when the time comes—you’re ready.

Work With Us

With a proven track record, the right skill sets, and years of experience, the Dwell Real Estate Team has the right tools to successfully achieve your goals. If you’re serious about your real estate plans, we’re serious about getting the job done!